March 29, 2023
Lawsuit Concerning Genetically Defective Mare Rejected

A lawsuit involving a genetically faulty horse that bodily regarded like a mare however was genetically male was voluntarily dismissed, based on a March 12 courtroom order.

Fayette (Ky.) Circuit Courtroom Decide Kimberly Bunnell dismissed the case with prejudice, that means the fees can’t be reinstated, and attorneys for plaintiff Michelle and Albert Crawford’s Crawford Farms will file a petition this week to have this case voluntarily dropped in Kentucky as effectively. Supreme Courtroom.

Bunnell’s order states that “the events have reached an Agreed Decision to voluntarily dismiss the motion” and doesn’t suggest that any settlement is said to the settlement.

The lawsuit, filed in June 2021, centered on the Stored True horse that Crawford Farms bought for $150,000 as a breeding mare candidate throughout the 2021 Keeneland January Horses of All Ages Sale. stored proper It was listed by Sure It is True as a winner of a New York-grown inventory for $323,659.

In accordance with courtroom paperwork, the Crawfords didn’t have the mare inspected earlier than eradicating them from Keeneland’s gross sales space. The mare then went to the Crawfords’ veterinarian, Dr. Jeremy Whitman and reported “apparent abnormalities within the horse’s reproductive organs” – particularly that the horse didn’t have ovaries. A follow-up karyotype take a look at by Texas A&M College revealed a genetic situation that confirmed the Stored True had “the looks of a feminine horse however the chromosomes of a male horse.”


Crawfords then contacted proprietor/breeder Jeff Treadway and shipper Hidden Brook Farm about canceling the sale and in search of reimbursement for his or her prices of sustaining Stored True. These requests had been each denied and led to a lawsuit through which Treadway, Hidden Brook, Keeneland, and Hagyard Equine Medical Institute had been named as defendants. Hagyard veterinarian Dr. Karen Wolfsdorf had signed a certificates required by Keeneland stating that, based on American Equine Practitioners Affiliation requirements, a breeding mare was pregnant or, if not pregnant, match to mate.

Downey: Go well with Winner Claims Broodmare Chance Is Male

Keeneland responded with a movement to dismiss, primarily based on numerous provisions within the phrases of sale; one was that the Crawfords had been contractually required to say no the sale inside 24 hours of the tip of the session through which the horse was current. Offered. The transfer was accepted.

Hidden Brook requested a abstract judgment by Bunnell on April 28, stating that in substance Crawfords’ declare in opposition to the shipper was barred as a result of Keeneland’s phrases of sale ruled all public sale transactions. Consumers will do all pre-sales testing and buy the horse “as is”. If a horse is discovered to be uncertified, the one answer is to refuse the sale, however that is solely inside the 24-hour window after a session. The Crawfords admitted in courtroom information that that they had not complied with the phrases of the sale, however appealed Bunnell’s determination, which dismissed the fees in opposition to Hidden Brook.

Hagyard and Wolfsdorf additionally filed a request for abstract judgment, however Bunnell refused, leaving the declare open for additional motion.

Treadway’s lawyer, the vendor of Stored True, offered a response to the criticism denying legal responsibility and cross-filed in opposition to Wolfsdorf if any damages had been assessed in opposition to him. The cross-claim was additionally resolved along with his March 12 dismissal.

Dick Downey contributed to this report.

#Lawsuit #Genetically #Faulty #Mare #Rejected

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *